30/04/2012

Dividend Policy: find the most suitable dividend pay back way

When talking about the shareholders’ wealth, the directly earning for them is the dividend. Therefore, making an appropriate dividend policy is very important for both the managers and shareholders. As the dividend policy defined as the determination of the proportion of profits paid out to shareholders-usually periodically. Thus it is important that firms should have a right level of dividend to the shareholder every time. For example, firms may pay dividends at higher level, same level, lower level or not pay dividends.
According to different people’s opinions, there are different dividend formulating methods. Modigliani & Millar (M&M) (1961) argue that if a few assumptions can be made, dividend policy is irrelevant to share price. The share prices are determined by future earning potential, not dividends paid now. Therefore, M&M point out that the share value is determined by investment policy, not by the amount of earning distributed.
On the other hand, Linter (1956) and Gordon (1959) argue that dividend policy is relevant to the share value. They claim that investors prefer to receive dividend rather than invest the same amount of dividend into the uncertain investments. Investors do not access internal information. Therefore, dividend is the only way to let them know the performance of firms well or not.
In the real world, there is an example that could illustrate even though the company’s EPS is increasing, the corporation’s future is still full of doubtable. The BBC news reported that Lloyds Banking Group has reported falling profits and set aside an extra £375m to pay for payment protection insurance (PPI) compensation. Pre-tax profit in the first quarter of 2012 was £288m, compared with a £3.5bn loss in the same period last year. Lloyds' boss said it "reflected the subdued UK economic environment".  Lloyds is 40%-owned by the government, said the extra PPI provisions were down to "the increase in the volume of complaints". Meanwhile, the bank said the profit figure was in line with its expectations and its share price rose 8.3% to close at 33.6 pence. Furthermore, compared with its profit loss performance, Lloyds’ EPS is increasing as well. In this case it is another imperative factor to attract the investors’ funds.
From the news we could understand that in some situations although the corporation in this year has a bad performance, in order to maintain the investors’ confidence the corporation would decrease the investment on the profitable project and uses those funds to increase the shareholders’ dividend incomes. In this case, it could successfully promote the company’s share price and apparently it looks like the company is in a good situation. Overall, when an investor chooses a proper share to invest, he or she should not only focus on the EPS. As the EPS could not entirely reflect the situation of the corporation and the investor should find the most right dividend pay back way for himself.

08/04/2012

Capital Structure: High Gearing means Beneficial??

Through the last few weeks’ study, I acknowledge that the most important part of this module is teaching us to understand the shareholders’ wealth and how to maximize those shareholders’ value. Although from different perspectives, there might be diversified methods to increase the shareholders’ value. As in terms of a corporation, the managers’ primary responsibility is operating the company’s financial capital structure in an appropriate level in order to ensure the interests of the shareholders, which is the point of this week’s study.
During the modern company’s developing process, the accumulation of capitals is a very essential part and in general a corporation’s operating capital is attracting from two ways: debt and ordinary share capital. Therefore, how to balance debt and equity became an imperative job for the managers. The traditional view believes that it would be beneficial to increase gearing from a low (or zero) level because the firm would then be financed to a greater extent by cheaper borrowed funds, therefore the weighted average cost of capital (WACC) would fall. The discounting of future cash flows at this lower WACC produces a higher present value and so shareholder wealth is enhanced. However, the debt must be controlled in a proper level which means there might be an optimal capital structure. It is because apparently it looks like the more debt the lower of WACC is, but in fact the debt levels rise the firm’s earning attributable to shareholders become increasingly volatile due to the requirement to pay large amounts of interests prior to dividend. Eventually the burden of a large annual interest bill can lead the firm to become financially distressed and, in extreme circumstances, to be liquidated.
Recently, Terra Firma, the private equity group chaired by Guy Hands, has agreed a £825m debt and equity deal for care home company Four Seasons Health Care. Four Seasons became the UK's largest elderly care provider last year after acquiring 140 homes from its defunct rival Southern Cross. The company said it is in a stronger position than Southern was because it owns approximately 60% of the homes and care centres it operates, thus limiting its exposure to rental costs. However, as its exposure depending on too much external debt and the company try to use the debt-for-equity swap with Royal Bank of Scotland to take a 40% stake in the company in return for a near halving of the debt mountain. Eventually, Four Seasons hope through this deal it could cut its debts and put the company on a more stable financial footing.
In this case the company’s development might harm those private shareholders’ interests as too much debt plays a detrimental influence on their dividends. More seriously, due to the over-optimal level debt, Four Seasons has to swap its equity in order to pay its debts, which could the private shareholders’ dividend decreases and loose the company’s control. Thus we should not ignore that although the high gearing could benefit decreasing the WACC and to a certain degree it might enhance the shareholders’ value. On the contrary, in the real world too much debt do not mean entirely beneficial for the shareholders’ wealth, as the risk increasing as well and the company’s cash flow facing a risk. Overall, a corporation should control the gearing in an appropriate level which means it should consistent with the corporation’s capability.

01/04/2012

Social Responsible Investment

Generally speaking, as a company exists in the contemporary world, it could not only operate its business without caring about its social responsibilities. Especially, in recently years, the socially responsible investing has been becoming a new fashion for investors. The socially responsible investing (SRI) is invest the money only based on non-financial factors especially the factors that related environment and ethical principles and regarding the profit. SRI recognizes that corporate responsibility and societal concerns are valid parts of investment decisions. SRI considers both the investor's financial needs and an investment’s impact on society. SRI investors encourage corporations to improve their practices on environmental, social, and governance issues.

Therefore, after the financial crisis in 2008 the capital market is confront with a series of reforms and restructures, which means an exciting new era for sustainable and responsible investment (SRI) is emerging. In terms of some investment houses, they tried to make some investment strategies associate with SRI principles in order to attracting more investors’ attention. For instance: The Henderson Global Investors, which recently restructured its approach to managing SRI funds. It faced clear rationalisation pressures given the breadth of its product portfolio after integrating New Star and Gartmore. As neither specialised in SRI, this business decision was not surprising. Reflecting what may become a wider trend, the specialist team moved to Wheb Asset Management, part of a sustainable investment group also covering private equity and infrastructure.
However, there are some factors still limiting the development of SRI trend. Most importantly, client demand for high quality asset stewardship remains a key concern. As an investment funds the most imperative objective is making the profit for its investors. Nevertheless, according to some evidences show that the UN-backed Principles for Responsible Investment have often become a short-listing requirement but anecdotal evidence suggests that demand for effective implementation remains patchy. Therefore, to some extent the contradiction between investor's financial needs and an investment’s impact on society could not be consistent and in the real operation it must need some regulation institutions to supervise those investment houses to comply with the SRI principles. Overall, although the financial benefits is imperative, the corporations should notice that once its investment processes some unethical trade which might result in a serious consequent that damage its original financial benefits.

26/03/2012

Credit Crisis: some suggestions of the banking regulation system in USA

In the past few weeks, I focused on the shareholder values that generated by some internal factors. While there are some external factors that we could not ignore. In contemporary world, a company’s business not only impacted by the micro-economic factors, but also impacted by several macro-economic factors. This week through the lecture study we acknowledged the reason of financial crisis in 2008. Most importantly, according to the Lehman Brother’s bankruptcy story we could understand the Credit Crisis in 2008.
Lehman Brothers which is one of the most venerable and biggest investment banks in the USA, as it investing too much funds into the housing-related assets and making it vulnerable to a downturn in that market, which caused the investment bank into a disastrous situation. During those periods its stock which is the most important barometer of market confidence was in free fall and essential funding was cut off. The federal government attempted to help, but then, at the last minute, lost its resolve. Consequently, Lehman Brothers announced bankruptcy and LEH was delisted from the NYSE.

From my perspective, in terms of the banking industry in the USA, although both Great Depression in 1933 and the global financial crisis in 2008 are derived from U.S. there is no deny that it is still the most advanced and vigorous market in the world. While there are still many things the USA regulation institution must do, they must realize that deregulation is accompanied by the effect of instability and many investment banks may engage in some illegal activities. Therefore, the regulation and supervision institution in the USA must discover a solution to resolve the detrimental effects that were resulted by the banking industry's deregulation, and the solution must have a positive impact on their financial market which means it will not restrict the development of finance. Overall, if the two largest economies in the world could learn from each other's experience, they might benefit from each other.

12/03/2012

Mergers&Acquisitions

When it comes to expanding the operation of a corporation, many people would like to talk about FDI and Mergers&Acquisitions (M&A). It is undoubted that M&A plays a very important role in corporate finance. For example, they help to ensure that the managers of a business act in the best financial interest of their shareholders by maximising the company’s share price. If the share price starts to slide, they know that they risk another company coming in and making takeover bid for the business which will almost certainly see the managers lose their well-paid jobs.
Actually, in the real world the M&A behaviours not only be impacted by the micro economy factors in the industry, but also influenced by the macro economy factors. A new report from PwC shows 2011 turned out to be a disappointing year for those with high hopes of a recovery in M&A. There were plenty of proposed deals, but many failed. The final tally of 639 announced deals was significantly lower than 2010’s 848, and made 2011 the worst year for deals since 2006. The value of the 207 announced deals that disclosed a figure was $15.4bn, compared with $29.5bn for 296 deals in 2010. PwC points out that not all announced deals close, even where the value is reported.( financial times)
Through this news, we could analysis that in 2011, the macro economy existed a host of uncertainty factors. In terms of western countries, during 2011 the United Sates’ government launched the Quantitative Loose Monetary Policy which in order to increase the liquidity of cash flow in its financial market and resolve the unbalance of its exporting trade difficulty. However, it also brings a series of negative consequences to the other countries. The most serious problem is that due to the dollars has dramatically increasing entered into the market, some countries who holding U.S. Treasury bonds are suffering severe losses. Especially, some new emerging market countries’ companies who planned to invest in the United Sates’ market, after the QE policy they had confronted with the problem that the U.S. dollars they owned are devaluated. Hence, although it seems like some industries in U.S. are starved of funding to assist to their recovery. In this situation they would not take the risk to merger another entity. In addition, in 2011 some area’s political situation is not stable and some places had broken out the revolutions, such as: Egypt, Libya and other Northern African regions. Thus, many companies would not want to take a risk to enter into the new emerging markets and the M&A behaviours in 2011 were not at a positive environment.
Accordingly, some micro factors also could impact the corporation’s decision. Youku, China’s leading online video company, and its closest rival Tudou are merging in a deal that raises hopes of creating a profitable market leader in the fast-growing but fiercely competitive industry. The two companies, both listed in the US, said on Monday they had signed a definitive agreement under which Tudou would combine with Youku in an all-share transaction. Youku will be the surviving entity following the deal. Youku shareholders will own 71.5 per cent of the combined company, and Tudou shareholders 28.5 per cent.

It is obviously seen from the news that those two corporations’ merger is due to they plan to expand their market power to face the fierce competition. As they are the two biggest video on-line watching companies in PR China, this merger could avoid the battle between them and provide them an opportunity to gain a more powerful position in the market. The companies said the deal could make that easier. “We expect to see significant synergies across a number of areas including leveraging licensed content over a larger user base and realising efficiencies in bandwidth management and other common expenses,” said Victor Koo, founder and chief executive of Youku. The merger deal is set to create a dominant market leader. Youku had a 21.8 per cent share of the Chinese online video market by advertising revenue in the fourth quarter, followed by Tudou with 13.7 per cent, according to Analysys.
However, I was worried about this behaviour for the customers and other companies in this market. As these two are the biggest video watching companies in China, it could easily give rise to the monopoly. Once a corporation has the monopoly position in this market, it could not benefit market competition and the monopoly company would not have the motivation to innovation and improve its management. Overall, this merger might cause these two companies monopolize the video watching resources and customers might hardly own the choice priority. More seriously, due to the government has been forbidding Youtube entering into China market, and it published a series of restricting policies in order to maintenance Chinese Communist Party’s rule. The citizens in PR China might not have the right to watch some relevant democracy and liberty video.

04/03/2012

Foreign Direct Investment--------FDI

The internationalization process itself, however, beings with international trade. Thus in order to acquire competitive advantages numerous MNEs have chosen to establish their foreign markets and invested a part of their funds into new emerging markets. In addition, in contemporary society foreign direct investment have played an essential role on most countries to encourage their economy growth and employment markets. Particularly, in some new emerging markets attracting foreign capital investment became an imperative part of those governments’ responsibilities. For instance: In 1978 PR China has made an economic policy named reform and open, through this policy during 30 years China have gained a significant success in the growth of its GDP which keeping stable increased about 8% every year. Besides, due to those foreign capitals entered into China’s market, many middle sized local companies have accumulated enough funds which benefited those enterprises’ growth. Such as: Lenovo group who has successfully purchased IBM’s desktop business and effectively acquired some shares of foreign market.
However, foreign capitals’ investing does not represent a positive situation, in the other word, it might have some defects. In terms of China, due to the dramatically entering of foreign capitals which have gave a rise to an overheating of the economy, especially in the real estate industry, the price of the real estate on an extremely high level which is not according with objective law. In this situation, a vast amount of foreign capitals are in real estate industry and other industries’ small sized companies hardly accumulated the funds, eventually widen the gap between rich and poor. More importantly, as a developing country like China, it could not always depend on labour-intensive manufactures to encourage sustainable development.
In a recent news from the Financial Times which said that with wages in China rising at about 12 per cent annually after adjusting for inflation over the past few years, it’s easy to think that lower-cost countries such as Bangladesh, Vietnam and Indonesia will benefit. But the conventional wisdom that China will attract less foreign direct investment (FDI) as manufacturing moves away is wrong, according to a new report from the Economist Intelligence Unit. The main beneficiaries from rising labour costs on China’s coasts are instead China’s inland provinces, which will attract huge amounts of FDI in coming years. There is an example to demonstrate this trend, The shift inland is already apparent in Chongqing in western China where party boss Bo Xilai has successfully made the investment climate attractive for the likes of Hewlett-Packard and others. The EIU points out that in 2007, Chongqing was ranked 22nd on a list of 31 provinces ranked by inbound FDI. Last year, it attracted as much as $11bn.

From my perspective, in the face of this trend seems like PR China is still a good choice investing land for the MNEs, especially though with wages rising in the coast provinces while many foreign capital companies moves to those inland provinces. What was more, as the about 13 million population in China means unpredictable cheap labours, remaining investments in PR China is a wise behaviour. On the contrary, investing return could be affected by a host of complicated factors. Due to the political environment in PR China is unstable and the gap between rich and poor has been widening. More seriously, as the economic system in China is not a completely marketization which means government’s interference could make a detrimental influence on foreign direct investment. Furthermore, the factor of economic development structure is not reasonable, which might slow down its GDP’s increase and from the long-term perspective China’s economic system must be reformed, which would cause the unstable of economy growth. Last not the least, according to recent years’ developing low-priced labours could not exist for a long period and many cheap resources have almost over consumed. Those competitive advantages for China became increasingly negative. Hence, MENs should change their investing strategy in time.

27/02/2012

Derivates


As the pace of globalization becomes more rapid and trade in different countries are increasingly frequent. Therefore, a international organization need to confront with diversified risks and foreign currency risks is one of those risks. The organizations prefer to use many measures to avoid the risks, some might use internal hedging and external hedging methods. In addition, the external hedging methods are considered to through some financial instruments to avoid those risks. 
At the beginning of 1990s deregulation and advances in technology lead to an explosion of complex financial products called derivatives, a derivative is a financial instrument for the management of some risks in the charge of stock market, interest rates and exchange rates. Using these products the investment banks could gamble on virtually anything and earning a great deal of profits and also help some individuals to earn much money.
Group Posadas SAB, Latin America’s largest hotel company, is in the process of getting rid of a “very high” percentage of its currency swap contracts after the peso’s rally this year, an official said. The company, which operates hotels in cities including Acapulco and Cancun, took out derivatives contracts to shift liabilities into dollars, matching them with revenue that’s partially denominated in the U.S. currency. The peso has gained 8.9 percent this year, tied with the Brazilian real for the most among 16 major currencies tracked by Bloomberg. Posadas has “significantly” decreased its peso derivatives positions after the currency’s rally, Ruben Camiro, the company’s Mexico City-based chief financial officer, said in a telephone interview yesterday. “The idea is to get rid of substantially all of them.” As the peso posted a Latin America-worst 11.4 percent loss in 2011, the company faced growing demands for collateral, known as margin calls, on $145 million in currency swap contracts it took out in 2008 to shift floating-rate peso debt into a fixed- rate dollar liability. The peso’s slide forced Posadas to set aside an additional $14 million in collateral, pushing the total amount deposited to $32 million by the end of September, tying up money the company may need to meet bank debt, according to Standard & Poor’s.
From the news above, it indicates that Posadas company plan to take out derivatives contracts to shift liabilities into dollars and match them with revenue that's partially denominated in the U.S. currency. On the other side, as the economy is reviving in some new emerging markets like Brazil, hence peso has gain 8.9 in this year. In this case, many people would like to invest in peso products while the company did not do that. It is because in last year due to the peso post a Latin America-worst 11.4 percent loss, the company be forced to set aside an additional $14 million in collateral. In this case, the company's shareholder value has became more risk and their interests are in threatened. Which means, the company should take out $14 million from its profit or other assets, it could make a detrimental effect on its investors. Thus, although in the beginning of this year, when peso shows a positive trend Posadas still decrease its peso derivatives. The group believed in this case it could get rid of substantially all of them. Which means the future currency market is hard to predict as after the global financial crisis most new emerging countries' increasing are not stable and in recently euro crisis happened. Therefore, Posadas should not pay its attention one one foreign currency and it might hold a rational percentage of different currency to protect itself from possible dramatically decline. 

19/02/2012

Capital Structure

In contemporary society, there are numerous ways of raising money for a corporation and the mostly implied approaches are through raising equiuty capital and debt finance. After the lecture study, the students also have a clearly recognition of the merits and defects between those two methods. Gernerally speaking, equity tends to have a higher risk but higher returns and debt a lower risk so this works out cheaper. It is because usually the lenders to the firm have no official control and they cannot choose directors or determine major strategic issue. While creditors bear relatively less risk than shareholders because debtors have legal obligation to pay interests to creditors regularly and return the principal on maturity date, and therefore creditors require a lower rate of return than ordinary shareholders.  So if a company plan to conrol its capiyal cost as low as possiable, it seems like increase its debt is a very appropriate way to choose. In addition, in terms of reducing the WACC effect, alter a company's capital structure by having a higher proportion of its capital in the form of cheaper debt that may be good choice for the company.

However, in pratical world why most companies do not merely try to increase their gearing and low the amount of equity? Admittedly,  when sourcing through debt the main thing to take into account is the benefit debt finance brings to the company through lowered levels of corporation tax. While there is very serious problem that we should not ignore when the firms run into a hard time, they still have the obligation to pay the interests to those creditors. To a certain extent that might cause a company bankruptcy. Moreover, by raising equity capital there is some advatanges as well. For instance: When losses are made the company does not have the problem of finding money for a dividend. Equity acts as a kind of shock absorber. Hence, an excellent capital structure should arrange a rational proportion of equity and debt.

From a recently news Swiss bank UBS AG preparing to sell a loss-absorbing bond, and from the regulator's point of view it could help eliminate taxpayer-led bailouts for struggling banks.The loss-absorbing bonds will comply with the new international and Swiss banking regulation being implemented in the wake of a credit crisis that pushed governments to rescue their biggest banks.

 Through this news indicates that when the bank is confront with the difficult of attracting funds from stock market, which is caused by the negative impact of European debt crisis and the slow growth of global economy. The bank has a choice to raising the capital through debt finance method, which mainly rely on selling the bonds like what UBS AG did. Furthermore, a famous International capital rules--known as Basel III--will require global bank capital to absorb losses through either a conversion to equity or a write-down. Hence, UBS's bond aligns with the latter. It will be permanently written down--completely wiping out a bondholder's investment--if the bank's core equity capital ratio drops below 5%. Obviously, this is a approach to prevent the banks' capital structure from the edge of bankruptcy. In the other words, as a bank in today's financial world, it not only does take the responsibility to allocate the money, but also have to keep the stability of the financial system. Therefore, when the bank's core equity capital ratio drops below 5% and UBS's bond will be permanetly written down, which means the bank try to prevent the bank from a dangerous situation in order to protect those depositors' interests. Moreover, UBS's behaviour could increase its gearing and lead to reduce the WACC. In this case, the shareholders' interests could be protected.

News from:http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052970204795304577222660449740178.html?mod=googlenews_wsj




 

11/02/2012

Stock market

In 2008, an unexpected financial crisis which is believed to have derived from the USA spread globally and rapidly. More seriously, it had triggered a severe economic recession in mos countries and the crisis have a long-term negative effects on the world economy until today. Undoubtedly, one of its reason is the lack of regulation in the USA's capital market. As we all know that after the Great Depression in 1929, the Wall Street bankers were facing serious criticism. Therefore, within this background the regulator published a famous law which named Glass-Steagall Act aimed to enhance the administration of capital market especially the stock market in America. After the Banking Act published, the USA had 40 years of economic growth without a single financial crisis and the financial industry was tightly regulated. Unfortunately, with the society developed dramatically, the demand of allocating the funds in a vast of industries and markets is increasing. Hence, the USA government decided to repeal the Banking Act of 1933 and the country started a ten year period of financial deregulation. The most obvious feature in this period is the capital market acquiring a significant development and many complex financial products exploded. 


In this situation the Stock market in America was dramatically developed which means many small corporations could acquire their demanded money more easily and via more vast market. It was widely know that new technique company usually prefer to attracting funds in Nasdaq market. Just like what Google do in 2004, it sold shares to the public for the first time like what was most of Silicon Valley's companies would choose. No matter Google, Microsoft or the other companies they all prefer to accumulating its demanded capital in the stock market which could illustrate that in contemporary financial world it play an imperative role on raising capital. Except the function of raising capital, many investors pay their attention on this market's venture and using those ventures to trade securities and enjoy the returns. Stock market is full of risks and opportunities which resulted by its natural unstable ability. As it could be easily affected by a vast number of factors.


After a stellar start to the year, it was bound to happen. The three main indexes on Wall Street each ended the week with a loss on Friday amid a disheartening euro debt picture.The Standard & Poor’s 500-stock index had risen in each of the five weeks since the start of the year, and on Thursday the Dow Jones industrial average had its highest close since May 19, 2008, before the financial crisis. However, by the end of this week, doubts about the euro zone debt crisis — an entrenched theme of 2011 — resurfaced to bully the major market indexes lower. A general strike, protests and political turmoil boiled over in Greece a day after the government reached a provisional deal on the terms of a new loan program. In this news show that the market was mostly affected by the economical factors. When Greece decided to begin a new loan program, it must make it original debt crisis more serious and in Europe there was a very severe argument about whether to lend enough financial assist to Greece and Italy. Overall, no matter the individual investors or companies appears worry about the world economy market which could be clearly see from the downturn in stock market. In the other word, the stock market could reflect the performance of the economy.

05/02/2012

Shareholder Wealth Maximisation

Generally speaking, a company has variety of objectives, such as: achieving a target market share, keeping employee agitation to a minimum or keeping survival.  However, in modern society most organisation intended to apply shareholder value maximization theory. As Adam Smith's idea of the ' invisible hand' which illustrated that individuals are mostly inclination of selfish and they often pursuing their own interests, in the other words a investor would only focus on the return on his investing project, not the responsibility the company should undertaken. In order to attracting more funds and expanding the scale of the corporation, it must comply the goal of maximizing the value of its shareholders. Which means the company should make investment and financing decision with the aim of maximizing long-term shareholder wealth. In addition, as a company' management team, it is believed that they should continuously work to create and maximise shareholder value within five approaches.

In recently, Stelios Haji-Ioannou, EasyJet's founder, has stepped up his battle with the budget airline’s management, aligning his campaign to vote down directors’ pay proposals with the broader UK debate over excessive executive pay. Sir Stelios, whose family owns 37 per cent of the group, has called on fellow shareholders to reject the motion on executive pay at EasyJet’s annual general meeting next month, on the grounds that returns on capital employed did not justify the bonuses proposed. It was because under the terms of the proposals, the management board would be granted £8m in shares if certain targets were achieved. EasyJet said on Monday: “If EasyJet achieves the return on capital employed [roce] target chosen over the next three years, the airline will be significantly exceeding the current performance of rival airlines like IAG, Lufthansa, Southwest, and JetBlue in what is expected to be a tough market.” 

Therefore, it could reflect from this news, EasyJet company apply the SWM theory to measure the performance of its management executives and relevant their bonus with its target return. To a certain degree, it could avoid the management board make the operating strategy far from the benefits of the organization's shareholders. Besides, one advantage of the SWM theory is easy to measure, it was because the shareholders should only care about their returns on this company. Basically, when a organization operate a project, the management board mostly focusing on maximizing the shareholders' value while not putting so much attention on something like the organization's responsibility. Thus, the shareholders evaluated the performance of the management board according to whether they achieved the target return or not. 

However, in the real world nothing is perfect and the SWM theory also have some defects. As we could imagine that if a company that acts like it only cares about shareholder value is a company that the public quickly begins to dislike and avoid. Therefore, this is one half of the paradox: trying to maximizing the shareholder value is not a good way to maximizing shareholder value. And the other half of the paradox is that trying to actually help people and improve society may be a good way of maximizing shareholders value. 

In this week, the famous social network giant Facebook announced to it will proceed initial public offerings and valuing the social network from $75 billion to $100 billion. What was more, in this IPO progress, Facebook picking Morgan Stanley to lead the deal and also Goldman Sachs is also expected to play a major role.A $10 billion Facebook offering would rank fourth among IPOs for US companies, behind Visa, General Motor Co. and AT&T wireless, according to Dealogic.It would rank the facebook as the biggest US internet offering ever replacing Google, which raised $1.9 billion in 2004 at a $23 billion valuation.

However, facebook's CEO Mark Zuckerberg had delayed the company's public offering progress. He believed that when the company began public offering it might against the facebook's core value that the most imperative thing is improving the service to satisfy the demands of users. From Mark Zuckerberg's perspective, the facebook's core competition capability is established on 500million users and he wanted to develop more users prior to attracting more investment into his company. As he believed once the company listed in Nasdaq market, to a certain degree satisfy the shareholder's demand might not consist with his company developing strategics and probably harm its users' benefits. He had said:" Facebook was not originally founded to be a company and its mission is not making money. It was built to accomplish a social mission that make the world more open and connected." Hence, it is not hard to understand why Mark Zuckerberg do not want to put his company into public market too early.

From my perspective, the fundamental of facebook is just like what Zuckerberg said is its 500 million users, and both its business and revenue is established on the social relationships of two or more individuals. Thus, the investors or shareholders should notice this point. While there is a paradox still existed between shareholders value and Zuckerberg's core strategy. When he wants to put more funds into improving services to the users, in the other hand the dividends which the shareholders earned would be not increased. Overall, I believed a public company indeed has obligation to maximize the value of shareholders value while it was not an excuse to avoid some social responsibilities and those public companies should also remember their profit and market share is from the costumers not only rely on the investors. That's why I think although facebook will be a public company but it will limit its data-mining and profit-generating activities by the requirements of remaining of real and significant value to users, which is point to keep the organization's relatively long-term prosperity.