Generally speaking, a company has variety of objectives, such as: achieving a target market share, keeping employee agitation to a minimum or keeping survival. However, in modern society most organisation intended to apply shareholder value maximization theory. As Adam Smith's idea of the ' invisible hand' which illustrated that individuals are mostly inclination of selfish and they often pursuing their own interests, in the other words a investor would only focus on the return on his investing project, not the responsibility the company should undertaken. In order to attracting more funds and expanding the scale of the corporation, it must comply the goal of maximizing the value of its shareholders. Which means the company should make investment and financing decision with the aim of maximizing long-term shareholder wealth. In addition, as a company' management team, it is believed that they should continuously work to create and maximise shareholder value within five approaches.
In recently, Stelios Haji-Ioannou, EasyJet's founder, has stepped up his battle with the budget airline’s management, aligning his campaign to vote down directors’ pay proposals with the broader UK debate over excessive executive pay. Sir Stelios, whose family owns 37 per cent of the group, has called on fellow shareholders to reject the motion on executive pay at EasyJet’s annual general meeting next month, on the grounds that returns on capital employed did not justify the bonuses proposed. It was because under the terms of the proposals, the management board would be granted £8m in shares if certain targets were achieved. EasyJet said on Monday: “If EasyJet achieves the return on capital employed [roce] target chosen over the next three years, the airline will be significantly exceeding the current performance of rival airlines like IAG, Lufthansa, Southwest, and JetBlue in what is expected to be a tough market.”
Therefore, it could reflect from this news, EasyJet company apply the SWM theory to measure the performance of its management executives and relevant their bonus with its target return. To a certain degree, it could avoid the management board make the operating strategy far from the benefits of the organization's shareholders. Besides, one advantage of the SWM theory is easy to measure, it was because the shareholders should only care about their returns on this company. Basically, when a organization operate a project, the management board mostly focusing on maximizing the shareholders' value while not putting so much attention on something like the organization's responsibility. Thus, the shareholders evaluated the performance of the management board according to whether they achieved the target return or not.
However, in the real world nothing is perfect and the SWM theory also have some defects. As we could imagine that if a company that acts like it only cares about shareholder value is a company that the public quickly begins to dislike and avoid. Therefore, this is one half of the paradox: trying to maximizing the shareholder value is not a good way to maximizing shareholder value. And the other half of the paradox is that trying to actually help people and improve society may be a good way of maximizing shareholders value.
In this week, the famous social network giant Facebook announced to it will proceed initial public offerings and valuing the social network from $75 billion to $100 billion. What was more, in this IPO progress, Facebook picking Morgan Stanley to lead the deal and also Goldman Sachs is also expected to play a major role.A $10 billion Facebook offering would rank fourth among IPOs for US companies, behind Visa, General Motor Co. and AT&T wireless, according to Dealogic.It would rank the facebook as the biggest US internet offering ever replacing Google, which raised $1.9 billion in 2004 at a $23 billion valuation.
However, facebook's CEO Mark Zuckerberg had delayed the company's public offering progress. He believed that when the company began public offering it might against the facebook's core value that the most imperative thing is improving the service to satisfy the demands of users. From Mark Zuckerberg's perspective, the facebook's core competition capability is established on 500million users and he wanted to develop more users prior to attracting more investment into his company. As he believed once the company listed in Nasdaq market, to a certain degree satisfy the shareholder's demand might not consist with his company developing strategics and probably harm its users' benefits. He had said:" Facebook was not originally founded to be a company and its mission is not making money. It was built to accomplish a social mission that make the world more open and connected." Hence, it is not hard to understand why Mark Zuckerberg do not want to put his company into public market too early.
From my perspective, the fundamental of facebook is just like what Zuckerberg said is its 500 million users, and both its business and revenue is established on the social relationships of two or more individuals. Thus, the investors or shareholders should notice this point. While there is a paradox still existed between shareholders value and Zuckerberg's core strategy. When he wants to put more funds into improving services to the users, in the other hand the dividends which the shareholders earned would be not increased. Overall, I believed a public company indeed has obligation to maximize the value of shareholders value while it was not an excuse to avoid some social responsibilities and those public companies should also remember their profit and market share is from the costumers not only rely on the investors. That's why I think although facebook will be a public company but it will limit its data-mining and profit-generating activities by the requirements of remaining of real and significant value to users, which is point to keep the organization's relatively long-term prosperity.