08/04/2012

Capital Structure: High Gearing means Beneficial??

Through the last few weeks’ study, I acknowledge that the most important part of this module is teaching us to understand the shareholders’ wealth and how to maximize those shareholders’ value. Although from different perspectives, there might be diversified methods to increase the shareholders’ value. As in terms of a corporation, the managers’ primary responsibility is operating the company’s financial capital structure in an appropriate level in order to ensure the interests of the shareholders, which is the point of this week’s study.
During the modern company’s developing process, the accumulation of capitals is a very essential part and in general a corporation’s operating capital is attracting from two ways: debt and ordinary share capital. Therefore, how to balance debt and equity became an imperative job for the managers. The traditional view believes that it would be beneficial to increase gearing from a low (or zero) level because the firm would then be financed to a greater extent by cheaper borrowed funds, therefore the weighted average cost of capital (WACC) would fall. The discounting of future cash flows at this lower WACC produces a higher present value and so shareholder wealth is enhanced. However, the debt must be controlled in a proper level which means there might be an optimal capital structure. It is because apparently it looks like the more debt the lower of WACC is, but in fact the debt levels rise the firm’s earning attributable to shareholders become increasingly volatile due to the requirement to pay large amounts of interests prior to dividend. Eventually the burden of a large annual interest bill can lead the firm to become financially distressed and, in extreme circumstances, to be liquidated.
Recently, Terra Firma, the private equity group chaired by Guy Hands, has agreed a £825m debt and equity deal for care home company Four Seasons Health Care. Four Seasons became the UK's largest elderly care provider last year after acquiring 140 homes from its defunct rival Southern Cross. The company said it is in a stronger position than Southern was because it owns approximately 60% of the homes and care centres it operates, thus limiting its exposure to rental costs. However, as its exposure depending on too much external debt and the company try to use the debt-for-equity swap with Royal Bank of Scotland to take a 40% stake in the company in return for a near halving of the debt mountain. Eventually, Four Seasons hope through this deal it could cut its debts and put the company on a more stable financial footing.
In this case the company’s development might harm those private shareholders’ interests as too much debt plays a detrimental influence on their dividends. More seriously, due to the over-optimal level debt, Four Seasons has to swap its equity in order to pay its debts, which could the private shareholders’ dividend decreases and loose the company’s control. Thus we should not ignore that although the high gearing could benefit decreasing the WACC and to a certain degree it might enhance the shareholders’ value. On the contrary, in the real world too much debt do not mean entirely beneficial for the shareholders’ wealth, as the risk increasing as well and the company’s cash flow facing a risk. Overall, a corporation should control the gearing in an appropriate level which means it should consistent with the corporation’s capability.

No comments:

Post a Comment