30/04/2012

Dividend Policy: find the most suitable dividend pay back way

When talking about the shareholders’ wealth, the directly earning for them is the dividend. Therefore, making an appropriate dividend policy is very important for both the managers and shareholders. As the dividend policy defined as the determination of the proportion of profits paid out to shareholders-usually periodically. Thus it is important that firms should have a right level of dividend to the shareholder every time. For example, firms may pay dividends at higher level, same level, lower level or not pay dividends.
According to different people’s opinions, there are different dividend formulating methods. Modigliani & Millar (M&M) (1961) argue that if a few assumptions can be made, dividend policy is irrelevant to share price. The share prices are determined by future earning potential, not dividends paid now. Therefore, M&M point out that the share value is determined by investment policy, not by the amount of earning distributed.
On the other hand, Linter (1956) and Gordon (1959) argue that dividend policy is relevant to the share value. They claim that investors prefer to receive dividend rather than invest the same amount of dividend into the uncertain investments. Investors do not access internal information. Therefore, dividend is the only way to let them know the performance of firms well or not.
In the real world, there is an example that could illustrate even though the company’s EPS is increasing, the corporation’s future is still full of doubtable. The BBC news reported that Lloyds Banking Group has reported falling profits and set aside an extra £375m to pay for payment protection insurance (PPI) compensation. Pre-tax profit in the first quarter of 2012 was £288m, compared with a £3.5bn loss in the same period last year. Lloyds' boss said it "reflected the subdued UK economic environment".  Lloyds is 40%-owned by the government, said the extra PPI provisions were down to "the increase in the volume of complaints". Meanwhile, the bank said the profit figure was in line with its expectations and its share price rose 8.3% to close at 33.6 pence. Furthermore, compared with its profit loss performance, Lloyds’ EPS is increasing as well. In this case it is another imperative factor to attract the investors’ funds.
From the news we could understand that in some situations although the corporation in this year has a bad performance, in order to maintain the investors’ confidence the corporation would decrease the investment on the profitable project and uses those funds to increase the shareholders’ dividend incomes. In this case, it could successfully promote the company’s share price and apparently it looks like the company is in a good situation. Overall, when an investor chooses a proper share to invest, he or she should not only focus on the EPS. As the EPS could not entirely reflect the situation of the corporation and the investor should find the most right dividend pay back way for himself.

08/04/2012

Capital Structure: High Gearing means Beneficial??

Through the last few weeks’ study, I acknowledge that the most important part of this module is teaching us to understand the shareholders’ wealth and how to maximize those shareholders’ value. Although from different perspectives, there might be diversified methods to increase the shareholders’ value. As in terms of a corporation, the managers’ primary responsibility is operating the company’s financial capital structure in an appropriate level in order to ensure the interests of the shareholders, which is the point of this week’s study.
During the modern company’s developing process, the accumulation of capitals is a very essential part and in general a corporation’s operating capital is attracting from two ways: debt and ordinary share capital. Therefore, how to balance debt and equity became an imperative job for the managers. The traditional view believes that it would be beneficial to increase gearing from a low (or zero) level because the firm would then be financed to a greater extent by cheaper borrowed funds, therefore the weighted average cost of capital (WACC) would fall. The discounting of future cash flows at this lower WACC produces a higher present value and so shareholder wealth is enhanced. However, the debt must be controlled in a proper level which means there might be an optimal capital structure. It is because apparently it looks like the more debt the lower of WACC is, but in fact the debt levels rise the firm’s earning attributable to shareholders become increasingly volatile due to the requirement to pay large amounts of interests prior to dividend. Eventually the burden of a large annual interest bill can lead the firm to become financially distressed and, in extreme circumstances, to be liquidated.
Recently, Terra Firma, the private equity group chaired by Guy Hands, has agreed a £825m debt and equity deal for care home company Four Seasons Health Care. Four Seasons became the UK's largest elderly care provider last year after acquiring 140 homes from its defunct rival Southern Cross. The company said it is in a stronger position than Southern was because it owns approximately 60% of the homes and care centres it operates, thus limiting its exposure to rental costs. However, as its exposure depending on too much external debt and the company try to use the debt-for-equity swap with Royal Bank of Scotland to take a 40% stake in the company in return for a near halving of the debt mountain. Eventually, Four Seasons hope through this deal it could cut its debts and put the company on a more stable financial footing.
In this case the company’s development might harm those private shareholders’ interests as too much debt plays a detrimental influence on their dividends. More seriously, due to the over-optimal level debt, Four Seasons has to swap its equity in order to pay its debts, which could the private shareholders’ dividend decreases and loose the company’s control. Thus we should not ignore that although the high gearing could benefit decreasing the WACC and to a certain degree it might enhance the shareholders’ value. On the contrary, in the real world too much debt do not mean entirely beneficial for the shareholders’ wealth, as the risk increasing as well and the company’s cash flow facing a risk. Overall, a corporation should control the gearing in an appropriate level which means it should consistent with the corporation’s capability.

01/04/2012

Social Responsible Investment

Generally speaking, as a company exists in the contemporary world, it could not only operate its business without caring about its social responsibilities. Especially, in recently years, the socially responsible investing has been becoming a new fashion for investors. The socially responsible investing (SRI) is invest the money only based on non-financial factors especially the factors that related environment and ethical principles and regarding the profit. SRI recognizes that corporate responsibility and societal concerns are valid parts of investment decisions. SRI considers both the investor's financial needs and an investment’s impact on society. SRI investors encourage corporations to improve their practices on environmental, social, and governance issues.

Therefore, after the financial crisis in 2008 the capital market is confront with a series of reforms and restructures, which means an exciting new era for sustainable and responsible investment (SRI) is emerging. In terms of some investment houses, they tried to make some investment strategies associate with SRI principles in order to attracting more investors’ attention. For instance: The Henderson Global Investors, which recently restructured its approach to managing SRI funds. It faced clear rationalisation pressures given the breadth of its product portfolio after integrating New Star and Gartmore. As neither specialised in SRI, this business decision was not surprising. Reflecting what may become a wider trend, the specialist team moved to Wheb Asset Management, part of a sustainable investment group also covering private equity and infrastructure.
However, there are some factors still limiting the development of SRI trend. Most importantly, client demand for high quality asset stewardship remains a key concern. As an investment funds the most imperative objective is making the profit for its investors. Nevertheless, according to some evidences show that the UN-backed Principles for Responsible Investment have often become a short-listing requirement but anecdotal evidence suggests that demand for effective implementation remains patchy. Therefore, to some extent the contradiction between investor's financial needs and an investment’s impact on society could not be consistent and in the real operation it must need some regulation institutions to supervise those investment houses to comply with the SRI principles. Overall, although the financial benefits is imperative, the corporations should notice that once its investment processes some unethical trade which might result in a serious consequent that damage its original financial benefits.